🔀 FortiSwitch FS-424E vs Cisco 9500-48Y4C
AI-powered analysis across 18 matched specifications
Performance Overview
Scores based on quantifiable specification values (1-10 scale)
Detailed Specifications
| Specification | FortiSwitch FS-424E Fortinet | Cisco Catalyst 9500-48Y4C Cisco |
|---|---|---|
| Key Metrics | ||
| Model / Part Number | FS-424E | C9500-48Y4C |
| Form Factor | 1U rack-mount | 1U rack-mount |
| Switching Capacity | 128 Gbps | 2.4 Tbps |
| Forwarding Rate | 190 Mpps | 1,785 Mpps |
| MAC Address Table Size | 16,384 | 128,000 |
| Networking | ||
| Access / Downlink Ports | 24 × GE RJ45 | 48 × 25G SFP28 |
| Uplink Ports | 4 × 10GE SFP+ (1GE SFP compatible) | 4 × 100G QSFP28 |
| Layer 3 Routing Protocols | OSPF, BGP, VRRP, static routes | -- |
| Stacking / Virtual Chassis | -- | StackWise Virtual (2-switch logical chassis) |
| MACsec Support | -- | IEEE 802.1AE (all ports) |
| Management | ||
| Management Interfaces | FortiLink, CLI, Web UI, SNMP | Cisco IOS-XE, DNA Center, SD-Access |
| Power | ||
| Power Supply | Redundant power supply support | Dual hot-swap AC/DC |
| Power Consumption | 23.6W max | 400W max |
| Physical / Environmental | ||
| Cooling | -- | Redundant fan trays |
| Weight | -- | 10.2 kg |
| Operating Temperature | 0°C to 50°C | -- |
| Security | ||
| Security Features | -- | MACsec IEEE 802.1AE on all ports |
| Software & OS Compatibility | ||
| Operating System / Software | -- | Cisco IOS-XE |
Expert Analysis
The FortiSwitch FS-424E and Cisco Catalyst 9500-48Y4C represent fundamentally different tiers of switching hardware, targeting distinct deployment scenarios within enterprise networks. The FortiSwitch offers a cost-effective, energy-efficient solution with 24 Gigabit Ethernet access ports and 4×10GE uplinks, making it well-suited for access layer deployments in small to medium-sized offices or as a managed edge switch. Its 128 Gbps switching capacity and 190 Mpps forwarding rate are adequate for typical access layer traffic, while FortiLink integration provides simplified management when paired with FortiGate security appliances. The Layer 3 routing capabilities (OSPF, BGP, VRRP) add flexibility for small-scale routing deployments.
The Cisco Catalyst 9500-48Y4C is a high-performance aggregation/core switch designed for data centre and campus backbone applications. With 48×25G SFP28 ports and 4×100G QSFP28 uplinks, it delivers 18.75 times more switching capacity (2.4 Tbps) and 9.4 times higher forwarding rate (1,785 Mpps) than the FortiSwitch. The StackWise Virtual capability allows two switches to operate as a single logical chassis, providing high availability and simplified management. MACsec encryption on all ports offers comprehensive data plane security, while Cisco IOS-XE provides mature, feature-rich network operating system capabilities. The trade-off is significantly higher power consumption (400W versus 23.6W) and substantially greater cost.
Value propositions differ markedly: the FortiSwitch delivers integrated security management and low operational costs for access layer deployments, while the Catalyst provides carrier-grade performance, scalability, and advanced features for aggregation/core roles. Organisations should select based on their specific performance requirements, existing infrastructure investments, and total cost of ownership considerations rather than seeking a universal 'best' switch.
Ready to proceed?
Want to compare different products or add more to this comparison?
Open Interactive Comparison Tool →