💾 HPE Alletra MP B10000 vs Dell PowerMax 8000 vs NetApp AFF A1K
AI-powered analysis across 27 matched specifications
Performance Overview
Scores based on quantifiable specification values (1-10 scale)
Detailed Specifications
| Specification | HPE Alletra Storage MP B10000 HPE | Dell PowerMax 8000 Dell Storage | AFF A1K NetApp |
|---|---|---|---|
| Key Metrics | |||
| Maximum Effective Capacity | 5.8 PB (switched) | Not specified | NAS: 176.3 PB (24-node); SAN: 88.1 PB (6-node) |
| Maximum IOPS | Not specified | 7.5 million per rack | Not specified |
| Maximum Bandwidth | Not specified | 350 GB/s sustained | Not specified |
| Read Latency | Not specified | Under 100μs | Not specified |
| Availability | 100% data availability guarantee | 99.9999% (6-nines) | 99.9999% (government-grade) |
| Data Reduction Ratio | 4:1 (deduplication + compression) | 3.5:1 average (dedup + compression) | Inline dedup, compression (ONTAP) |
| Compute | |||
| Processor | AMD EPYC 3rd Gen: 32-core / 16-core / 8-core | Not specified | Not specified |
| Controller Nodes | 2, 3, or 4 controller nodes per solution | Not specified | Dual 2U chassis HA pair; NAS: up to 24 nodes; SAN: up to 6 nodes |
| Controller Memory | 32-core: 512 GB per node; 16-core/8-core: 256 GB per node | Not specified | 2048 GB per controller |
| Memory | |||
| Cache | 32-core: 512 GB per controller node; 16-core/8-core: 256 GB per controller node | Not specified | Not specified |
| Storage | |||
| Drive Description | NVMe SSD: 1.92 TB, 3.84 TB, 7.68 TB, 15.36 TB, 30.72 TB (TLC & QLC) | End-to-end NVMe (eMLC + QLC SSD) | Not specified |
| Maximum Raw Capacity | Up to 5.8 PB effective (switched); Up to 1.1 PB per solution (switchless) | Not specified | 14.7 PB per HA pair |
| Drives per Enclosure | 24 NVMe SSDs per 2U enclosure | Not specified | Not specified |
| Media Type | NVMe SSD (TLC & QLC) | End-to-end NVMe (eMLC + QLC SSD) | Not specified |
| Cloud Tiering | Not specified | AWS S3, Azure Blob, Dell ECS, S3-compatible | FabricPool (ONTAP) |
| Networking | |||
| Host Interface / Connectivity | 32Gb/s Fibre Channel; 10/25GbE iSCSI; NVMe-over-TCP | FC 32Gb, NVMe-oF, iSCSI 25G, FICON | 24× 200Gbps, 36× 100GbE, 56× 25GbE Ethernet; 56× 64Gbps NVMe/FC, FC |
| Protocols Supported | Block (iSCSI, FC), File (NFS, SMB), Object (S3) | FC, NVMe-oF, iSCSI, FICON | NVMe/FC, NVMe/TCP, NFSv3/RDMA, NFSv4/RDMA, FC, iSCSI, NFS, SMB/CIFS, S3 |
| GPU / Accelerators | |||
| GPU Support | -- | -- | -- |
| Expansion / PCIe | |||
| PCIe Expansion | Not specified | Not specified | 18 slots per controller |
| I/O & Ports | |||
| Host Ports | 32Gb FC, 10/25GbE iSCSI, NVMe-over-TCP | 32Gb FC, 25Gb iSCSI, NVMe-oF, FICON | 24× 200Gbps, 36× 100GbE, 56× 25GbE Ethernet; 56× 64Gbps NVMe/FC, FC |
| Management | |||
| Management Platform | HPE GreenLake Cloud (AI-driven, SaaS-based) | AI-driven data placement | NetApp ONTAP 9.16.1 (min. 9.15.1RC2) |
| Power | |||
| Power Specifications | -- | -- | -- |
| Physical / Environmental | |||
| Form Factor | 2U per enclosure | Rack-mounted (multiple enclosures) | Dual 2U chassis HA pair (modular); 1 HA controller per 2U chassis |
| Security | |||
| Security Features | Not specified | Not specified | AES-256, FIPS 140-2, SnapLock, ARP, Ransomware Recovery Guarantee |
| Software & OS Compatibility | |||
| Operating System / Software | HPE GreenLake Cloud | Open systems + IBM z/OS mainframe + IBM i | NetApp ONTAP 9.16.1 (min. 9.15.1RC2) |
| vVol Support | Not specified | Up to 64,000 VMware vVols | Not specified |
| Warranty & Support | |||
| Warranty | 1-year parts-only (hardware); support contract required | Not specified | Flex hardware support — 3 or 5 year options |
Expert Analysis
These three enterprise storage arrays represent distinct approaches to high-performance data management, each excelling in different scenarios. The HPE Alletra Storage MP B10000 offers a compelling unified platform with block, file, and object support on a single system, making it particularly suitable for organisations seeking to consolidate diverse workloads. Its 100% data availability guarantee and flexible scaling through disaggregated architecture provide strong value for mixed-use environments, though its 1-year hardware warranty requires careful support planning.
The Dell PowerMax 8000 stands out for extreme performance metrics, delivering 7.5 million IOPS per rack with sub-100μs latency—ideal for mission-critical transactional workloads requiring maximum throughput. Its 6-nines availability and SRDF/Metro active/active disaster recovery make it a strong contender for financial services and high-frequency trading applications, though its 3.5:1 data reduction ratio trails slightly behind competitors.
NetApp's AFF A1K demonstrates exceptional scalability and networking capabilities, supporting up to 176.3 PB in NAS configurations with 24×200Gbps Ethernet ports. Its government-grade 6-nines availability, comprehensive security features including ransomware recovery guarantee, and flexible 3-5 year warranty options make it particularly suitable for regulated industries and large-scale data lakes. The 2,048 GB controller memory provides substantial headroom for demanding workloads, though organisations should consider the complexity of managing its extensive protocol support.
Ready to proceed?
Want to compare different products or add more to this comparison?
Open Interactive Comparison Tool →