Performance Overview
Scores based on quantifiable specification values (1-10 scale)
Detailed Specifications
Frequently asked questions
Which is more powerful, the P1 Gen 8 or the P16 Gen 3?
The P16 Gen 3 has the higher ceiling on every axis that matters for heavy workloads. Its Core Ultra HX silicon reaches 24 cores against the P1's 16-core H-series, its graphics scale to the RTX PRO 5000 with 24 GB against the P1's RTX PRO 2000 with 8 GB, and memory runs to 192 GB versus 64 GB. The P1 Gen 8 trades that headroom for a far more portable chassis.
How much lighter and thinner is the P1 Gen 8?
Substantially. The ThinkPad P1 Gen 8 starts at 1.84 kg and is 20.6 mm at its thickest, whereas the P16 Gen 3 starts at 2.54 kg and reaches 29.8 mm. That roughly 700 g gap, plus the P1's smaller 140 W adapter against the P16's 180 W brick, is the practical difference between a machine you carry all day and a desktop replacement.
Can I upgrade the memory on both models?
Yes, but differently. The P1 Gen 8 uses a single LPCAMM2 module rather than soldered memory, so it stays serviceable to 64 GB of LPDDR5X — unusual for a thin workstation. The P16 Gen 3 is the more expandable machine: four DDR5-5600 SO-DIMM slots reach 192 GB non-ECC or 128 GB with ECC DIMMs, with stocked builds leaving two slots free for a mid-life upgrade.
Which should a UK fleet standardise on?
It depends on where the work happens. Choose the P1 Gen 8 for consultants and engineers who need RTX PRO acceleration but travel constantly, and value the light chassis and upgradeable memory. Choose the P16 Gen 3 for desk-bound or studio users running simulation, GPU rendering or large-model AI, or field teams needing 2.5GbE and optional 5G. Both ship a vPro Enterprise build and Windows 11 Pro.
Ready to proceed?
Want to compare different products or add more to this comparison?
Open Interactive Comparison Tool →Talk to a UK specialist
Get expert advice or a no-obligation quote — servers, storage, networking, maintenance, finance and cloud. We reply the same working day.

