🔀 Cisco Catalyst 3850 (legacy) vs 9300-48T
AI-powered analysis across 29 matched specifications
Performance Overview
Scores based on quantifiable specification values (1-10 scale)
Detailed Specifications
| Specification | Cisco Catalyst 3850 / 3750-X Cisco | Cisco Catalyst 9300-48T Cisco |
|---|---|---|
| Key Metrics | ||
| Access ports | 48 × 1GbE (3850-48 variant) | 48 × 10/100/1000 RJ45 |
| Uplink ports | 4 × 1G SFP or 2/4 × 10G SFP+ (modular) | 4 × 10G SFP+ (modular, up to 8 × 10G or 2 × 40G) |
| Stacking bandwidth | StackWise-480 (480 Gbps) | StackWise-480 (480 Gbps) |
| Stack members | Up to 9 | Up to 8 |
| Lifecycle status | End-of-sale / end-of-support | Current — actively shipping |
| Refresh recommendation | Replace with Catalyst 9300 | N/A — current generation |
| Forwarding & ASIC | ||
| ASIC | Fixed-function (UADP 1.0 era) | UADP 2.0 programmable |
| Switching capacity | 176 Gbps (48-port model) | 208 Gbps |
| Forwarding rate | 130.95 Mpps | Up to 1 Bpps (with full uplinks) |
| Layer 3 routing | OSPF, BGP, EIGRP (IP Services) | OSPF, BGP, EIGRP, IS-IS (Network Advantage) |
| Programmability | Limited — CLI-driven | NETCONF, RESTCONF, gRPC, YANG, Python on-box |
| Security & Encryption | ||
| MACsec | MACsec-128 on selected ports | MACsec-256 on all 48 ports (hardware) |
| TrustSec / SGT | Supported | Supported (inline tagging at line rate) |
| SD-Access fabric edge | -- | Yes — full DNA Center / Catalyst Center fabric edge |
| Encrypted Traffic Analytics | -- | Yes |
| Secure boot / image signing | Limited | Trust Anchor module, secure boot, runtime defences |
| Management & Operations | ||
| Operating system | IOS-XE 16.x (final supported) | IOS-XE 17.x (current train) |
| Controller | Cisco Prime (legacy) | Catalyst Center (formerly DNA Center) + Meraki Dashboard option |
| Telemetry | SNMP, syslog | Model-driven streaming telemetry, SNMP, syslog |
| Software licensing | Perpetual feature sets (IP Base / IP Services) | DNA Essentials/Advantage subscription + Network Essentials/Advantage |
| Cloud monitoring | -- | Meraki Dashboard onboarding supported |
| Power & Physical | ||
| PoE budget (PoE+ variant) | Up to 715 W (1100 W with dual PSU) | Up to 715 W (1100 W with dual PSU); UPOE/UPOE+ on other SKUs |
| PoE standards | PoE+ (802.3at), UPOE on select models | PoE+, UPOE, UPOE+ (90 W) on -U/-H SKUs |
| Redundant PSU | Yes (dual field-replaceable) | Yes (dual field-replaceable, platinum-rated) |
| Form factor | 1U | 1U |
| Lifecycle & Support | ||
| End-of-sale | October 2019 (3850); October 2016 (3750-X) | Actively shipping |
| End of software maintenance | October 2022 (3850) | TBA — current |
| Last day of support | October 2025 (3850); October 2021 (3750-X) | TBA — current |
| Smart Licensing | Partial (later IOS-XE only) | Native Smart Licensing Using Policy |
Expert Analysis
The headline difference is lifecycle, not feature parity. The Catalyst 3850 was the dominant enterprise access switch of its generation and, on a quiet wiring closet, still moves packets perfectly well — but it is past end-of-software-maintenance and the 3850 family reaches last-day-of-support in October 2025. From a UK compliance angle (Cyber Essentials Plus, NCSC guidance on supported software, NIS2 for in-scope operators), keeping 3850s in production beyond that date is increasingly hard to defend on an audit.
The 9300-48T is the direct, like-for-like refresh. The port count, 1U form factor and StackWise-480 stacking are deliberately familiar, so cabling, stack cables and rack layouts carry over. What you actually gain sits underneath: the UADP 2.0 programmable ASIC, line-rate MACsec-256 on every port, hardware Trust Anchor, model-driven telemetry, and — crucially — eligibility as an SD-Access fabric edge under Catalyst Center. If you have any intention of running TrustSec micro-segmentation, ETA, or a controller-driven campus fabric, the 3850 cannot get you there and the 9300 is the entry ticket.
The honest trade-off is the licensing model. The 3850 shipped with perpetual IP Base or IP Services; the 9300 requires a DNA/Network subscription (Essentials or Advantage) on top of the hardware, which changes the TCO conversation. Buyers used to a one-off capex line need to budget for the recurring element, and should size Advantage vs Essentials against whether they actually intend to use SD-Access, ETA and assurance features — paying for Advantage and running it like a dumb L2 switch is wasted money.
Recommendation: if you are specifying new access-layer kit in 2024–2025, there is no scenario in which the 3850 is the right answer — buy 9300-48T (or 9300L/9300X variants where the price/feature mix fits). Keep 3850s only where they are already deployed, fully depreciated, and on a documented refresh plan before the October 2025 LDoS. For PoE-heavy deployments (IP phones, Wi-Fi 6E APs, PoE cameras) look at the 9300-48P/48U/48H rather than the data-only 48T.
Ready to proceed?
Not sure which one fits your environment?
Our UK specialists will recommend the right option for your workload and send itemised pricing — vendor-neutral, no obligation.
Response within 4 business hours · 20+ yr UK reseller
Want to compare different products or add more to this comparison?
Open Interactive Comparison Tool →Made your choice? Spread the cost.
Whichever you choose, you don't have to pay for it all upfront — finance your new hardware from £172/mo ex VAT on hire purchase or lease. Compare monthly payments and terms in seconds.
See finance from £172/mo →Indicative estimate · subject to change · no credit check at this stage · hire purchase, lease & subscription for UK businesses
Indicative illustration only. Servnet Limited is not authorised or regulated by the FCA and does not provide financial advice or arrange finance. All finance opportunities are referred to Number Eight Business Finance. Finance policy
Talk to a UK specialist
Get expert advice or a no-obligation quote — servers, storage, networking, maintenance, finance and cloud. We reply the same working day.